We’re here to take a look at two intriguing and much-loved North American fish: the Tilapia and Bluegill. These fish are sought after for many reasons, including their taste and for the experience of catching them. There’s a lot of discussion these days in the aquaculture world about possibly raising Bluegill the way we raise Tilapia for a food source. Let’s get into what makes these fish unique.
Is a Tilapia the Same as a Bluegill?
No, Tilapia and Bluegill are not the same, although they share some characteristics. Tilapia is actually an umbrella term for several types of cichlid, freshwater-loving fish that thrive in warm temps. The Bluegill is a specific species of fish in the Sunfish family.
What’s the Difference Between Tilapia vs Bluegill?
When it comes down to it, Tilapia and Bluegill have very different physical characteristics though they look similar at first. We’ll dissect just what stands out about each species to help you tell them apart.
Most people throughout the world prefer Tilapia to Bluegill when it comes to frying up some fish, however Bluegill is a fish that few anglers turn down when they’re looking for a meal. The difference is, Tilapia is available on the market and can be found in many grocery stores.
Additionally, catching Tilapia and Bluegill requires a different set of gear and techniques.
Signup for my monthly newsletter to get content and gear recommendations every month. I'll send you stuff I like, I will never spam you.
What is a Tilapia?
Tilapia is a freshwater fish that is found throughout the world, including North America. In some areas, Tilapia thrive so well that they’re considered invasive. These vegetarian fish are actually cichlids, a species popular as food, game, and hobby fish.
What is a Bluegill?
The Bluegill, Lepomis macrochirus, is a freshwater fish that belongs to the Sunfish family. It’s sought-after for its great taste and big attitude despite their smaller size. Bluegill put up a good fight, but can be caught on less cumbersome gear. They’re native to North America.
How to Tell the Difference Bluegill vs Tilapia
There are quite a few ways to tell which fish you have on your line: Tilapia or Bluegill. First, their physical appearance. Size, spines, and coloration can all determine which species you’re looking at. Bluegill and Tilapia also prefer different habitats and prey.
Tilapia vs Bluegill Size Differences
Tilapia tend to be on the smaller size, which is unsurprising considering that many cichlids are kept as hobby fish at home. In the wild or in aquaculture farms, Tilapia can reach 10 lbs in weight. On average, they usually only get to 1.5 – 2.5 lbs.
Bluegill are not a part of aquaculture (fish farming) and weigh roughly 2 lbs in their natural habitat. The world record Bluegill hit 4 lbs, a great size for this species. Due to their smaller size and deep bodies, Bluegill are considered panfish – easy to fry up in a pan.
Tilapia vs Bluegill Dorsal Spines
Tilapia, despite being made up of a variety of cichlids, generally have 16-17 dorsal spines.
Bluegill have much fewer, with only 9-11 dorsal spines total.
Tilapia vs Bluegill Coloration Differences
The Bluegill earned its name from, unsurprisingly, the blue coloration along its gills. However the rest of the body varies in color. The backs and sides of the Bluegill are olive with yellow and green pebbling. Bellies are bright orange or yellow, and there’s usually a dark spot at the rear of the dorsal fin that can help you easily identify this species.
Tilapia come in a wide variety of colors, but let’s focus on the top three Tilapia species found in the US:
Nile Tilapia – Compared to other species, the Nile Tilapia may look boring. The body of this fish is bronze or a dull gray with white coloration along the ventral side and dark barring running vertically.
Mozambique Tilapia – Mozambiques have a greener or yellow body, but still have a dullness to them. Banding may be visible but is not as strong as in the Nile Tilapia.
Blue Tilapia – Blue Tilapia are, unsurprisingly, blue-grey. They have a white belly and red or pink coloration on the caudal fin.
Where Can You Find Bluegill?
Bluegill are native to most of North America and have one of the widest ranges of North American freshwater fish. They can be found along the east coast running down to Florida, west to Texas, into northern Mexico, northwest to Minnesota, and back east to New York. They’ve also been introduced outside of North America.
Bluegill Fishing Tips
Finding and catching Bluegill is also about knowing their territory and habits. Bluegill hang out among vegetation and you’ll need gear that can handle not getting hung up on mats of vegetation or underwater structures. They prefer waters ranging from 60-80 F and stay in shady areas out of direct sunlight.
Bluegill have a varied diet, meaning you can try out a variety of lures and rigs. They’ll go after live bait such as worms or insects, but are also attracted to artificial rigs like the Mule Donkey Tail Jr. or soft baits. The best Bluegill lures mimic their natural prey.
Where Can You Find Tilapia?
Most of the Tilapia in the US are in aquaculture farms, however you can find them in water sources most often in the southern states. Florida and Texas have prime Tilapia habitat, with warm waters and vegetation.
Tilapia Fishing Tips
Tilapia seek out warmth. The warmer the water, the more likely there is to be a population of Tilapia around. Keep this in mind when you’re fishing for Tilapia. These fish can be found in streams, rivers, lakes, ponds, and even brackish water sources. Tilapia are vegetarians and feed mostly on algae. On farms, they’re fed soybean or corn meal. Look for natural water sources with heavy vegetation and algae.
You’ll have to get creative with your bait since Tilapia don’t go after the usual suspects. Try out corn, peas, or even pieces of bread, as recommended by seasoned anglers.
Can you Find Bluegill and Tilapia Together?
Theoretically you’ll be able to find Bluegill and Tilapia living in some of the same water sources. However, due to the Tilapia’s preferences for much warmer waters, chances are that’ll be down south. Bluegill have a wide range that crosses over with many other species. The water source where you find both fish will need to be healthy enough to support both Bluegill prey (insects, small fish, crustaceans) and a thriving vegetated area with algae.
In conclusion, it’s easy to see why so many people love these fish. Not only are they good eating, they can be a challenge to find and fun to catch. If you’re considering going after both, make sure you have the correct gear – and bait – on hand. Happy fishing!
Yellow Perch vs Walleye – Which Taste Better?
Yellow Perch and Walleye are two species that are sometimes confused. Learn the difference between yellow perch vs walleyes in this post!
Green Sunfish vs Warmouth – What Is The Difference
Green Sunfish and Warmouth are two freshwater species that look very similar in appearance. Here are the best ways to tell them apart.